BoxyCharm Savings Calculator
Select Your Subscription
Your Savings Breakdown
What You Get
Four to six full-size beauty products with retail value $80-$130
Real Example
BoxyCharm isn’t just another beauty box-it’s one of the few that actually delivers more value than you pay for. But if you’ve ever wondered whether it’s worth the monthly fee, you’re not alone. People are asking: Is BoxyCharm expensive? Is it a rip-off? Or is it the smartest way to discover high-end makeup without spending hundreds at Sephora? Let’s cut through the noise.
What You Actually Pay for BoxyCharm
In 2026, BoxyCharm offers three subscription tiers. The most popular is the BoxyCharm Classic, which costs $29 per month. That’s it. No hidden fees. No surprise charges. You get four to six full-size beauty products every month, all curated around your profile. The average retail value of those products? Usually between $80 and $130. That means you’re saving at least $50 every single month, even before tax.
There’s also BoxyCharm Premium at $49 per month. This one includes five to seven full-size items, often with luxury brands like Too Faced, Rare Beauty, or Fenty Beauty. The retail value here regularly hits $150-$200. If you’re someone who buys high-end makeup anyway, this tier pays for itself in one box.
And then there’s BoxyCharm Basics-a $19 option for those who want to dip their toes in. It’s three to four full-size products, mostly skincare and drugstore staples. It’s not the glam squad, but it’s a solid entry point if you’re unsure whether you’ll even use the box.
Why People Think BoxyCharm Is Expensive (And Why They’re Wrong)
Sometimes, the price feels steep because you’re comparing it to other subscription boxes like Ipsy or FabFitFun. But those boxes mostly send samples. BoxyCharm sends full-size. A full-size lipstick from Charlotte Tilbury costs $34 at retail. A full-size foundation from NARS? $45. BoxyCharm doesn’t send miniatures-you get the real thing.
One subscriber in Toronto got a full-size Rare Beauty Soft Pinch Tint in 2025. That product retails for $24. She’d never have bought it on its own because she didn’t know her shade. But BoxyCharm sent it in her perfect tone. She used it for six months. That’s $24 she didn’t spend on a risky online purchase.
Another user in Melbourne got a full-size Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz. Retail price: $26. She’d been eyeing it for months but kept putting it off. The box gave her a reason to try it-and now it’s her go-to. That’s not a subscription. That’s a discovery tool.
What You Get Inside the Box (Real Examples)
Don’t just take my word for it. Here’s what a typical BoxyCharm Classic box looked like in December 2025:
- Full-size Rare Beauty Soft Pinch Tint in ‘Bliss’ ($24 retail)
- Full-size Morphe x James Charles Palette ($38 retail)
- Full-size NYX Professional Makeup Total Control Drop Foundation ($19 retail)
- Full-size e.l.f. Cosmetics Poreless Putty Primer ($12 retail)
- Full-size Tower 28 ShineOn Lip Jelly in ‘Sunny’ ($16 retail)
Total retail value: $109. Cost to you: $29. That’s a 73% discount. And that’s not unusual. Boxes from late 2024 to early 2026 consistently hit 60-80% savings.
BoxyCharm Premium? In January 2026, one box included:
- Full-size Fenty Beauty Pro Filt’r Soft Matte Longwear Foundation ($38)
- Full-size Tatcha The Silk Canvas Primer ($58)
- Full-size Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Lipstick ($34)
- Full-size Dr. Jart+ Ceramidin Cream ($52)
- Full-size Tower 28 Beauty SuperDew Highlighter ($22)
Total retail value: $204. Cost to you: $49. That’s an 76% discount. You’re not paying for a box. You’re paying for access to luxury brands you’d never try otherwise.
Who BoxyCharm Is For (And Who Should Skip It)
BoxyCharm makes sense if:
- You love trying new makeup but hate wasting money on products you don’t like
- You’re curious about luxury brands but don’t want to buy full-size upfront
- You’ve tried sample boxes and felt cheated because everything was tiny
- You’re okay with surprise products-you don’t need to pick every item
BoxyCharm isn’t for you if:
- You only use drugstore makeup and refuse to try higher-end brands
- You need to control every product in your box (some people get frustrated when they don’t recognize a brand)
- You’re on a tight budget and $29/month feels like a stretch
- You already have a full makeup collection and don’t need new products
One user in Auckland told me she canceled after six months because she was overwhelmed with lipstick. She didn’t wear it often. But she said, “I got three lipsticks I love now. I’d pay $29 again just for those.” That’s the real math.
Hidden Costs? Shipping, Taxes, and Cancellations
BoxyCharm ships free within the U.S. and Canada. If you’re in Australia or New Zealand, shipping is $15 flat per box. That’s not cheap-but it’s still less than the cost of one full-size lipstick. And you’re still saving 50-70% on the products themselves.
Taxes? They’re added at checkout based on your location. In New Zealand, GST applies to the box price and shipping. So a $29 box + $15 shipping = $44 before tax. Add 15% GST = $50.60 total. Still a steal if the retail value is $100+.
Cancellation? Easy. You can pause or cancel anytime before the 5th of the month. No penalty. No trick questions. No “we’ll charge you for the next box anyway.”
How BoxyCharm Compares to Other Beauty Boxes
Here’s how BoxyCharm stacks up against the competition in early 2026:
| Box | Price | Product Type | Monthly Value | Shipping to NZ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BoxyCharm Classic | $29 | Full-size makeup | $80-$130 | $15 |
| BoxyCharm Premium | $49 | Full-size luxury makeup + skincare | $150-$200 | $15 |
| Ipsy Glam Bag | $13 | Miniatures (mostly) | $35-$50 | $12 |
| FabFitFun | $49 | Beauty, fitness, home | $120-$180 | $10 |
| BeautyBox (AU) | $25 | Full-size skincare | $70-$90 | Free |
BoxyCharm wins on product size. Ipsy sends you five mini lipsticks. BoxyCharm sends you one full-size lipstick you’ll actually use. FabFitFun gives you a candle and a yoga mat. BoxyCharm gives you a foundation you’ll finish in two months. If your goal is to build your makeup collection without overspending, BoxyCharm is the only one that delivers.
Is BoxyCharm Worth It in 2026?
Yes-if you’re willing to let go of control. You don’t get to pick every item. You might get a product you don’t love. But you’ll also get at least two or three you didn’t know you needed. And you’ll pay less than half the retail price.
Think of it like this: if you spent $29 every month on one new lipstick, you’d have 12 lipsticks a year. With BoxyCharm, you get 12 full-size products, plus a primer, a palette, a foundation, and a cream. That’s not just makeup. That’s a full beauty routine.
And if you’re worried about wasting money? You can cancel anytime. You’re not locked in. You can try it for three months, see what you get, and decide if it’s right for you. No risk. Just real value.
BoxyCharm isn’t expensive. It’s a smart way to buy beauty. And if you’re still not sure? Start with the $19 Basics box. You’ll know in one month whether it’s worth the jump.
Is BoxyCharm worth the price?
Yes, if you want full-size products and don’t mind surprises. The average retail value of each Classic box is $80-$130, but you pay just $29. Even with international shipping, you’re saving 60-80%. You’re not paying for a box-you’re paying for access to luxury products you’d never buy on your own.
Does BoxyCharm ship to New Zealand?
Yes, BoxyCharm ships to New Zealand for a flat $15 fee per box. While that adds to the cost, the retail value of the products inside still far exceeds the total price. For example, a $29 box with $110 in retail value plus $15 shipping still gives you over 60% savings.
Can I cancel BoxyCharm anytime?
Yes. You can pause or cancel your subscription anytime before the 5th of the month. There’s no penalty, no contract, and no hidden fees. You won’t be charged for the next box if you cancel in time.
Are the products in BoxyCharm full-size?
Yes. Unlike most beauty boxes that send samples, BoxyCharm sends full-size makeup and skincare products. A lipstick, foundation, or cream you receive is the same size you’d buy in-store. This is what makes BoxyCharm stand out from Ipsy or other sample-based boxes.
What’s the difference between BoxyCharm Classic and Premium?
BoxyCharm Classic ($29/month) includes 4-6 full-size makeup products, mostly from mid-tier to luxury brands. BoxyCharm Premium ($49/month) includes 5-7 items with higher-end brands like Fenty Beauty, Tatcha, and Dr. Jart+, often adding skincare to the mix. Premium boxes have higher retail value ($150-$200) and are ideal for those who already invest in luxury beauty.
Is BoxyCharm better than Ipsy?
It depends on what you want. Ipsy ($13/month) sends mostly miniatures and is great for trying new brands on a budget. BoxyCharm sends full-size products and is better for building a real makeup collection. If you’re tired of tiny samples and want products you’ll actually finish, BoxyCharm is the better long-term value.
Next Steps: How to Start
If you’re ready to try BoxyCharm, go to their website and take the beauty quiz. It asks about your skin tone, preferred brands, and makeup habits. That’s how they customize your box. Start with the $19 Basics box if you’re unsure. You’ll get three full-size products and know in one month whether it’s worth upgrading.
And if you’re still hesitating? Remember: you can cancel anytime. But if you wait too long, you might miss out on a box with a $45 foundation you’d never have bought on your own.